If there is data available on current impacts, then the analyst can dig
deeper into current impacts addressing the tasks of trend detection in
the data (see Toolbox section on Detection of trends via
statistical methods), and attributing this trend to
anthropogenic climate change or to other drivers (see Toolbox section
on Attribution
of impacts). Trend detection may involve both socio-economic
and biophysical systems, as is the case with detecting trends in
damages from tropical storms. This is discussed in detail in the
Toolbox section Describing
current impacts.
Detected trends in
impacts can be attributed to climate change or other drivers either
using process-based models or building statistical models of the
relationship between observed impacts and a number of explanatory
variables. Most scholarly work in CCVIA focuses on the explanation of
impacts through biophysical variables and are labeled here impact
attribution. Some work also tries to explain impacts through
socio-economic variables. These approaches are sometimes also called
vulnerability or adaptive capacity indicators in the literature,
however they differ from the vulnerability indicators described above
in that the latter ones do not consider data on observed impacts (Yohe
and Tol 2002; Hinkel 2011a). In order to avoid confusion, we only use
the term vulnerability indicator for those approaches that do not use
data on observed impacts, as described above.
When
no trend is discernable in the data or the trend cannot be attributed
to climate change, then impact analysis cannot be carried further and
the identification of vulnerability must exclusively rely on
vulnerability and capacity indication (see the decision tree on choosing
approaches to capacity analysis and the Toolbox section on Vulnerability
indication).
This section is based on the UNEP PROVIA guidance document |
1. | You want to assess vulnerability. | |
2. | Your focus is on impacts. | |
3. | Either no studies on future impacts are available, or available studies are not comprehensive or credible. | |
4. | Impact models to simulate future impacts are not available. | |
5. | Data on observed impacts is available. | |
6. | Detection and attribution have been performed. | |
7. | As a next step you are faced with the question whether there is a trend atributable to climate change. |